1
Is Planned Change Still Useful? Lewin, Kotter and Their Critics
Student Name
Department, University Name
Leadership and Change Management
Professor Name
12 November 2026
Is Planned Change Still Useful? Lewin, Kotter and Their Critics
Organisations change constantly, yet many change programmes fail to deliver what they promise. Two models dominate how managers are taught to plan change: Kurt Lewin’s three-step model and John Kotter’s eight steps. This essay outlines both, examines the main criticisms made by writers who see change as emergent rather than planned, and argues that planned models remain useful as frameworks for thinking, provided they are not followed as recipes.
Lewin’s Three-Step Model
Lewin (1947) described change as moving a group from one quasi-stationary equilibrium to another. The present state must first be unfrozen, by weakening the forces that hold it in place; the group then moves to new behaviours; and the new state is refrozen so that it does not slide back. The model is usually presented as a simple linear sequence. Burnes (2004) argues that this reading is a caricature: Lewin saw the three steps as part of a wider approach that included field theory, group dynamics and action research, and he treated change as a participative, learning process rather than a top-down instruction.
Kotter’s Eight Steps
Kotter (1995) built his model from observing why transformation efforts fail. His eight steps begin with establishing a sense of urgency and forming a powerful guiding coalition, move through creating and communicating a vision, empowering others to act and generating short-term wins, and end by consolidating improvements and anchoring the new approaches in the culture (Kotter, 1996). The model translates Lewin’s logic into managerial actions: the first steps unfreeze, the middle steps move, and the last steps refreeze.
The model’s strength is practical. It names common failure points, such as declaring victory too soon or under-communicating the vision, and gives leaders a checklist for avoiding them. Its weakness is the same practicality: it was derived from consulting experience rather than systematic testing, and its sequence implies a degree of control over people and events that few managers actually have.
The Emergent Critique
Writers on emergent change argue that in turbulent environments change is continuous, unpredictable and shaped by many local decisions rather than a single plan. By (2005) reviews the field and concludes that there is little empirical evidence for any one change approach, and that the widely quoted claim that most change programmes fail rests on weak evidence. From this view, planned models risk encouraging leaders to treat resistance as a problem to be managed rather than as information about what the change means to those affected.
Evaluation
The critique is persuasive where planned models are used as rigid scripts. Yet it does not show that planning is useless. Many changes, such as introducing a new system or merging two departments, have a clear end point and benefit from deliberate sequencing, communication and reinforcement. Burnes (2004) shows that Lewin himself combined planning with participation and learning, which narrows the gap between the planned and emergent camps. A balanced position is that planned models help managers ask the right questions, such as why people would want to change and what will hold the new behaviour in place, while emergent thinking reminds them that the answers will change as the work unfolds.
Conclusion
Planned change models remain useful, but as frameworks rather than formulas. Lewin’s insight that stability must be loosened before change can hold, and Kotter’s attention to urgency, coalitions and quick wins, still describe real challenges. Their limits appear when they are applied mechanically to complex, fast-moving situations. Managers who combine the structure of planned models with the participation and adaptability stressed by their critics are more likely to make change that lasts.
Reference list
Burnes, B. (2004) ‘Kurt Lewin and the planned approach to change: a re-appraisal’, Journal of Management Studies, 41(6), pp. 977–1002.
By, R.T. (2005) ‘Organisational change management: a critical review’, Journal of Change Management, 5(4), pp. 369–380.
Kotter, J.P. (1995) ‘Leading change: why transformation efforts fail’, Harvard Business Review, 73(2), pp. 59–67.
Kotter, J.P. (1996) Leading change. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
Lewin, K. (1947) ‘Frontiers in group dynamics: concept, method and reality in social science; social equilibria and social change’, Human Relations, 1(1), pp. 5–41.
Sample paper by Professor Eric · For study and reference only. Do not submit it as your own work.