1
What Do Milgram’s Obedience Studies Really Show?
Student Name
Department, University Name
Social Psychology
Professor Name
12 November 2026
What Do Milgram’s Obedience Studies Really Show?
Few studies in psychology are as famous, or as disputed, as Stanley Milgram’s research on obedience to authority. Milgram (1963) reported that a majority of ordinary participants continued to administer what they believed were dangerous electric shocks to another person when instructed to do so by an experimenter. This essay outlines the original findings, considers ethical and methodological criticisms, and argues that the studies show less about blind obedience than about identification with the goals of an authority.
The Original Findings
Participants were told that the study investigated learning. Acting as a ‘teacher’, each was asked to give increasing shocks to a ‘learner’, in fact a confederate who received no shocks, whenever he made an error. In the baseline condition, 26 of 40 participants continued to the maximum level (Milgram, 1963). Many showed obvious distress, sweating and protesting, yet continued when the experimenter used scripted prods such as ‘the experiment requires that you continue’. Milgram concluded that people readily enter an agentic state in which they see themselves as instruments of another’s will.
Milgram went on to run many variations of the procedure. Obedience fell when the learner was in the same room, when the teacher had to place the learner’s hand on a shock plate, when the experimenter gave instructions by telephone, and when two other ‘teachers’ refused to continue. These variations are often cited as evidence that situational factors, rather than personality, drive obedience. They also show that obedience was never a fixed rate but depended heavily on how the situation was arranged.
Ethical Criticism
Baumrind (1964) argued that the research caused participants serious stress, deceived them and risked lasting harm to their self-image, without sufficient justification. These concerns helped shape modern research ethics, including informed consent, the right to withdraw and thorough debriefing. They also mean that the original procedure could not be repeated today.
Methodological questions have also been raised. Some participants may have suspected that the shocks were not real, which would weaken the claim that they believed they were causing harm. The sample in the baseline study consisted of American men recruited by advertisement, which limits how far the findings can be generalised. Milgram replied that follow-up questionnaires showed most participants believed the situation and did not regret taking part, but critics note that such reports may themselves be shaped by the wish to justify one’s own behaviour.
Replication and Reinterpretation
Burger (2009) found a way to replicate part of the study ethically by stopping at the point where the learner first protests, which in Milgram’s data strongly predicted going on to the end. Obedience rates at that point were only slightly lower than Milgram’s, suggesting the effect had not simply vanished with changing times.
However, the nature of the effect is debated. Haslam and Reicher (2012) note that the prod most resembling a direct order, ‘you have no other choice, you must go on’, was the least effective, and that obedience varied greatly across Milgram’s own variations. They propose an engaged followership account: people continued when they identified with the experimenter and the scientific project, and stopped when they identified more with the learner. On this view, harm arises not from mindless conformity but from people believing they are doing something worthwhile.
Conclusion
Milgram’s studies remain a powerful demonstration that ordinary people can inflict harm under the influence of a legitimate authority. Yet the evidence does not support a simple picture of passive obedience. Variation across conditions and the weak effect of direct orders suggest that identification with the authority’s goals is central. The research therefore warns not only about authority but about how worthy causes can be used to justify harm.
Reference list
Baumrind, D. (1964) ‘Some thoughts on ethics of research: after reading Milgram’s “Behavioral study of obedience”’, American Psychologist, 19(6), pp. 421–423.
Burger, J.M. (2009) ‘Replicating Milgram: would people still obey today?’, American Psychologist, 64(1), pp. 1–11.
Haslam, S.A. and Reicher, S.D. (2012) ‘Contesting the “nature” of conformity: what Milgram and Zimbardo’s studies really show’, PLoS Biology, 10(11), e1001426.
Milgram, S. (1963) ‘Behavioral study of obedience’, Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, 67(4), pp. 371–378.
Sample paper by Professor Eric · For study and reference only. Do not submit it as your own work.