1
Fair Value or Historical Cost? Choosing a Measurement Basis for Financial Reporting
Student Name
Department, University Name
ACC 310: Intermediate Financial Accounting
Professor Name
12 November 2026
Fair Value or Historical Cost? Choosing a Measurement Basis for Financial Reporting
Every number on a balance sheet rests on a choice about how to measure it. An asset can be shown at what the company paid for it or at what it would fetch in the market today. This choice between historical cost and fair value shapes reported profit, the strength of the balance sheet and the decisions of investors who rely on both. This essay sets out the case for each basis, considers the evidence on how investors use accounting numbers, and argues that neither basis is best for every item, which is why modern standards use a mixture.
The Case for Historical Cost
Historical cost records an asset at the price paid, adjusted only for depreciation and impairment. Its great strength is reliability: the figure is supported by a transaction that actually occurred and can be verified by an auditor. It is also less exposed to management judgement, because it does not depend on estimates of market prices that may not exist. Watts and Zimmerman (1978) argued that managers have incentives to choose accounting methods that serve their own interests, which strengthens the case for measures that leave little room for discretion. The weakness of historical cost is relevance: the price paid for land decades ago may say very little about what the land is worth now.
The Case for Fair Value
Fair value measures an asset at the price that would be received to sell it in an orderly transaction between market participants. For assets traded in active markets, such as listed shares, this figure is both relevant and easy to verify. The Conceptual Framework issued by the International Accounting Standards Board treats relevance and faithful representation as the fundamental qualities of useful information, and fair value often scores well on relevance because it reflects current conditions (IASB, 2018). Investors analysing a bank’s holdings of securities, for example, need to know what those holdings are worth today rather than what they cost. Fair value also removes a known distortion of historical cost: under cost-based measurement, a firm can report gains simply by choosing when to sell assets that have quietly risen in value, a practice sometimes called gains trading.
The difficulty arises when no active market exists. Then fair value must be estimated using models and assumptions, and the resulting figure may be neither verifiable nor neutral. Critics also argue that marking assets to market can amplify financial cycles: when prices fall, reported losses may force sales that drive prices lower still.
What the Evidence Suggests
Research on how investors use accounting information supports the view that reported numbers matter. Ball and Brown (1968) showed that share prices move in the direction of unexpected changes in reported earnings, although much of the movement occurs before the announcement as information reaches the market from other sources. Later studies suggest that fair value information about financial instruments is reflected in share prices when markets are active, but that investors discount estimates based on unobservable inputs.
Conclusion
The debate between historical cost and fair value is best resolved item by item rather than as a single choice. Fair value is most useful where reliable market prices exist and where current values drive decisions, as with financial instruments. Historical cost remains appropriate for operating assets that a firm intends to use rather than sell, where market estimates add volatility without improving decisions. Current standards reflect exactly this mixed approach, supported by disclosures that let users see which figures rest on market prices and which on management estimates.
References
Ball, R., & Brown, P. (1968). An empirical evaluation of accounting income numbers. Journal of Accounting Research, 6(2), 159–178.
International Accounting Standards Board. (2018). Conceptual framework for financial reporting. IFRS Foundation.
Watts, R. L., & Zimmerman, J. L. (1978). Towards a positive theory of the determination of accounting standards. The Accounting Review, 53(1), 112–134.
Sample paper by Professor Eric · For study and reference only. Do not submit it as your own work.