The problem
Two overlapping standards can make outcomes harder to predict and arguments harder to frame.
Where a gap may lie: Recent case law invites fresh evaluation of whether the distinction still does useful work.
Possible research questions
- How do Wednesbury and proportionality differ in structure and intensity?
- Have the courts moved towards a single flexible standard?
- Would replacing Wednesbury improve legal certainty and accountability?
Possible objectives
- Trace the development of both standards.
- Analyse leading appellate decisions.
- Reach a reasoned conclusion on reform.
Theories and frameworks to consider
- Separation of powers
- Constitutional deference and institutional competence
Designs and methods that could fit
- Doctrinal analysis of appellate case law
- Critical evaluation of academic commentary
Search terms for your literature review
- judicial review
- proportionality
- Wednesbury
- administrative law
- human rights
This topic is a starting point for your own research, not a ready-made or approved dissertation. Check the current literature to confirm the gap, and agree your question with your supervisor.